Saturday, 7 April 2012

Rohit Arya on Thomas Kinkade- avatar of the third rate


 

One does not get to be so terribly bad as an artist as Thomas Kinkade was without putting in a great deal of effort; grim, determined, wilfully deaf to sense effort. He was a grotesquely appalling  artist, so very bad it almost made it into the ‘so bad it is good’ category but his sheer third rate ness ? made him a phenomenon of rubbish. He was basically an illustrator of sentimental Christmas cards in the manner favoured by Victorians; by some inexplicable aberration of destiny , he succeeded to the point of selling up to 100 million dollars a year worth of  his ‘art’. That was his own claim, and its accuracy is perhaps moot. But a man with such a sublime self -regard as to describe himself as a ‘painter of light’ – his oeuvre resembling  homesteads gone radioactive – and also as “America’s most collected living artist” has to get his uncanny confidence somewhere. High sales and a fat bank balance are as good as explanation as any. How else did he have the temerity to compare himself to Disney and be intensely content that he is a nice man who “likes to make people happy”. I do not begrudge him his good fortune. If there are enough philistines out there to buy your work, well why not? He was the painterly equivalent of J.K. Rowling, though the creator of Potter is occasionally talented. Kinkade was sublimely awful at all times.

 

I blame Tolkien. The sheer popularity of hobbit-y matters in popular culture provided the fertile soil for such tortured weeds. Kinkade’s houses look like hobbit holes, and his landscapes like the countryside after Samwise Gamgee has used the magic dust given him by Galadriel to replenish the land.   It is, to be quite blunt, visual titties to be sucked on by the visually unimaginative . A kinder explanation is that the houses and ‘scapes of Kinkade are so popular precisely because they do not exist anymore, if they ever did.   They represent a deep yearning for the myth of pastoral that is hard wired in the human soul, or at least of the middle classes. These impossibly pretty pictures are not admired for their own sake .It is hard to believe that anybody with a reasonable education - and having the money to buy Kinkade presumes that – would classify these excrescences as art. They bypass the logic circuits and take you into a dream world that you are secretly, irrevocably convinced you deserve to live in.  A Kinkade house is the ideal… what is distressing is how many people share the identical vision of uniqueness!   

 

It is easy to lament the general ignorance of the public, but nobody finds it strange that the public has bad taste in movies and books and music. Why should it not be so in art? The spectacle of a third rate dauber getting rich has led to all the vitriol against him, because there is no doubt at all that the art is rot.  That such rot can be so popular, and even worse lucrative, is what agitates people. It is uncomfortable  in the implications it raises. Art, which should be in business of raising consciousness, of challenging everything, of stimulating ideas and facilitating thought, can be subverted into valium for the intellectually lazy. Sincere human endeavour can still lead to unimpressive, even untoward, results. It is a horrible thought. But now Kinkade  is gone, April 7, 2012 and the space is clear for someone else with more luck and confidence than talent to test the intriguing notion that popularity is validity and celebrity is credibility.





Rohit Arya is the Editor of The Leadership Review, and a corporate trainer. He has been a cultural critic and social commentator for two decades. Rohit is the author of 5 books and been published in 5 European languages. He is an Author, Yogi, Polymath. Rohit is also a Lineage Master in the Eight Spiritual Breaths system of Yoga

No comments:

Post a Comment