Friday, 30 March 2012

Rohit Arya-The Indian film song finally takes Hollywood




 It’s been a 100 years but India’s greatest and most original contribution to cinema – the film song – has decisively penetrated the most influential film industry - Hollywood.  If popular art is an unacknowledged precursor to social shifts this might just be the most buoyant thing to happen to that famously hopeful unicorn – India’s soft power. A mainstream Hollywood film –“ Mirror, Mirror” with Julia Roberts as the evil stepmother of Snow White no less - culminates with  a ‘filmy’ number,  Lily Collins singing “I believe in love” and Sean Bean remains alive at the end of the film! Nothing will ever be the same. This will not immediately translate into homages and remakes but I predict the increasing influence of India in Hollywood films will be dated from this day. The sort of sentimental and lengthy films that mainstream  Hollywood prefers today when Indians are going in for darker themes and shorter films is an inversion that has not been noticed. This is just the most hilarious and awkward merging of genres I have ever seen… and Tarsem Singh continues to make crap films that look gorgeous. But that song at the end is the end of the beginning; India has won, and the outrageous, implausible, contributes- nothing- to- the- narrative warble has now come to be accepted as a valid aesthetic and creative choice .

 

Tarsem Singh dug this particular song out of his childhood memory of the ‘70s when an Iranian singer  did a cover version that was an inexplicable rage. It is the sort of tune that young people love and their parents grimace over… a reaction that continued at the test screenings of the film. It almost got scrapped by the studio but Singh is a very persuasive man and he kept it in. The story of how they located the original artist, Nina Hart, is much more interesting  than any magic mirror but that is another story. Read it here… it is worth it
What I find remarkable however is the creative choice the director made to end a film. The Princess is about to make a speech after the Triumph over Evil and instead she launches into what is a Hindi film song – you cannot say it is anything else. It has wavy hand movements and back up dwarves and odd noises and twirling, a lot of twirling… all the people magically learn the moves to keep in tune,  as in India, and Sean Bean looks completely flummoxed as to what is happening, which just might be the most scary thing you will see. The problem here is that Tarsem is not Tarantino and he simply does not have the batshit crazy confidence in himself to cut loose and go over the top which is actually the only way to do these songs… if you accept even for a nano-second they are implausible and preposterous you are dead. Lily Collins would never get a lead in an Indian film – heroine’s best friend would be her slot – but she is game enough, and delivers with vim. Singh, in  trying to tone down the camp only accentuates how absurd these songs and their situations actually are. Still, the very fact that a die-hard staple of the Western fairy tale canon got a revisionist twist via an Indian film song is actually quite noteworthy.  It is not the Disney song number, this is another species altogether, and I suspect it will prove to be an invasive species, crowding out the original members of the habitat.
 


An American originally writes and records this song. An Iranian singer does a cover version that gives her a lot of fame, before she seems to be erased socially. An Indian boy living in Punjab in the 1970s remembers it and tests it out years later on his niece who loves it, while he is mangling a movie he is directing on Greek mythology. It ends up as the finale of a German fairy tale, sung by the daughter of Phil Collins, who however has never sung before. You can’t make this stuff up! It is as good as a masala film. Whether that is good for films in general remains to be seen, but the incredible Indian film song has forced its way into respectability and acceptance. India always wins … because it endures… and because it ignores anything it doesn’t like to hear while enduring.  A century of relentless criticism against the film song was unheeded because audiences liked it enough and cinematic grammar be damned. Now the foot is in the door and curious things are liable to happen.  

 Rohit Arya is the Editor of The Leadership Review, and a corporate trainer. He has been a cultural critic for two decades. Rohit is the author of 5 books and been published in 5 European languages. He is an Author, Yogi, Polymath

Thursday, 1 March 2012

Rohit Arya reviews 13 Assassins

 
“Being a Samurai is truly a burden”

What is Duty? For that matter Loyalty? And why should people live by such concepts? This is the core dilemma in the surprising and brilliant 13 Assassins which is not just the most incredible action movie you will see after The Matrix. It is ultimately a rumination on entelechy, what is a man’s destiny when juxtaposed with his duty? What is honour, justice, service? Do any of them mean anything when the rich and powerful stay snug and the other ranks fight to preserve value? I watched the film because I had read about mind-bending action and for once the reports could not convey the sheer dazzling lunacy of inspiration the fight scenes achieve. When a fight begins with a stampede of bulls set on fire and becomes progressively demented after that you are in for a very good time. But the movie is dangerous and valuable because it takes morals and ethics seriously and expects viewers to do the same.  Takashii Miike is famous for his prolific output and infamous for Audition, a movie that creeped me out, and I like Oldboy! 13 Assassins is not as good as Seven Samurai – what is? – but it is a clever re-examination of the entire credo of bushido, and  fabulously entertaining to boot. To expect so much from a film is almost immature nowadays. 

The basic plot is very simple. The half-brother of the current Shogun of Japan in the year 1844 is going to be promoted next year into what will be the second most impart job. The issue at stake is that Naritsugu is a peculiar monster, who rapes and mutilates and massacres and murders for no reason other than that he can. His evil is never explained, and that is wise. Real evil never needs to be explained. Ultimately people do bad things because they can. But Naritsugu seems to have been driven insane by the fact that he has never learnt the joys of deferred gratification. He gets what he wants, and he assumes that means he can take what he wants and do what he wants also. Nobody ever really challenges him- his social position is too high for that. So he casually rapes his host’s daughter in law and murders the son, and when one of his officials decorously protests by committing hara-kiri, he round up the family of the man and shots arrows at them, taking care to keep the children alive and witnessing the slaughter. He just seems bored, in the manner a petulant child is bored and whines for entertainment. He even eats like an animal apparently for the sheer novelty of it. Cutting off limbs and tongues of girls who fail to please him are also part of his repertorie. This last bit of sadism is too much for the retired Samurai Shimada Shinzameon to overlook and he accepts a directive from senior official Sir Doi to assassinate this pestilential troll.


 “I will accomplish your wish with magnificence.”
It is worth nothing that Doi has been given his instructions by the Shogun, and he finds Shimada to do his dirty work. The retired samurai is finding his life boring; he can fish, but he is terribly alone. The need for a noble death is sharpened by the crushing loneliness he feels; he is so lonely even a very impolite late night summons is a welcome respite. But when he sees the tortured girl his anger flares up. He had made the sensible suggestion that the Shogun should retire his brother. Naturally that is not an option. Face is everything. But in the end over 250 people have to die so that this one nuisance can be removed from the body politic. A culture that puts such a cheap price on blood, that has no problem asking for such promiscuous spilling of blood, instead of doing the sensible rational thing, is not a culture that was going to last very long. The rich and powerful remain secure; the middle levels have to do all the heavy lifting, shoulder the blame, and protect society. A large part of Shimada’s anger is also the realization that he and his kind were bulwarks of a system that allowed such a poisonous weed to flourish.
Shimada is still a very respected, if not famous samurai and he finds no problem in assembling a team of assassins, including a dissolute gambler nephew who does not like being a Samurai, but is hugely talented as a warrior. Shimada’s protégé is a great swordsman and he brings his protégé along, who seeks to gain social status in death. A yari- spear – master joins them, asking for money to pay off debts, purchase burial plots for his dead wife and his own self and one immersion into the pleasures he could never afford. He wants them to know he is not doing it just for the money for such people can be purchased away. In his desire to fulfil desires before he dies he is actually quite wise. When he sees the actual size of the enemy, 200 as against the anticipated 70, he wryly comments.  “You got me for a real bargain” but then plunges into the melee and kills tremendously before being finally overpowered.  This sublime acceptance of hard- nosed reality while simultaneously also enacting noble principles is a peculiar dance that only the Japanese were skilful at. 

 


“What is the concern of a Samurai?”
Naritsugu however is protected by Hanbei, who actually went to the same dojo as Shimada and knows they are in serious trouble if he is coming after them. He suffers from a sense of unfairness. He is almost as skilled and able as Shimada, but did not have the family background and connections to prosper as his friend did. Now he finally seems to have a shot at the big time. He is the real spirit of the clan, and once his lord becomes prominent in Japan he will flourish too. This assassination, no matter how much he agrees with it in his heart, will permanently halt him in mediocrity. So aware is he what is at stake that he actually advices the quiet swallowing of humiliation on the road home till the next year when their posts will be secure.  Naritsugu, having never suffered deprivation or being seated below the salt cannot account for this unwonted timorousness in his right hand and urges rashness as “it is always the more interesting choice.” Hanbei cannot respect his master, and therefore himself, but his need to prove himself a success is greater than his decency. He is a cunning old fox too, with a great spy network, and not above sending assassins of his own to wipe out this threat. He knows that on the annual trip back to their lands from the capital, Shimada will strike, but he does everything possible to stop it.

 


“We must trust in luck”
Shimada chooses a no account village, Ochiai in the path of the clans’ way home to make their stand. He purchases the villagers out and booby traps the entire space. He also makes sure that the only other road is barred to Naritsugu. Again the willingness of the middle level samurai to take upon themselves the blame for the evil their masters wish them to do is striking. The samurai who lost his son and daughter in law blocks and humiliates Naitsugu; Hanbei allows it to see which way the wind is blowing and realizes resistance to his masters tyranny has awakened. The official who barred the way commits seppuku thus saving his Masters face and rendering him officially blameless. Naritsugu enters and even though Hanbei deduces a trap, it is too late as the bridge behind them is blown up. They have to fight thru or die. The assassins are waiting their number strengthened by a wild man of the jungle they picked up.

 


“Total Massacre”
What follows is 45 minutes of the most incredible, spheres to the wall, unfragging- believable action you will see in many, many years. They begin by setting bulls on fire and using the beasts to trample the soldiers. Then they use the rooftops to launch an arrow shower and even explosives go boom. The soldiers can’t use their muskets as it had been raining and a good thing too or the film would have been over. But Hanbei had used his time well and instead of 70 there are 200 soldiers trapped in the village. There is no alternative but to kill them all and get to Naritsugu. And here again, in this complete willingness of sensible and stupid people alike to die for what they all know is despicable scum is a huge question of culture and its values. The young look to the noble and supposedly wise elders as role models. The elders stiffen the upper lip and dispense bromides – “Samurai da!” – Indeed a true samurai. Is that really what a person would say and feel when he sees a young protégé, almost like a son die? Amazingly that is probably true. Culture is a feedback loop and approval and mores flow in both directions of the generational divide. The young mirror the stoic nobility of the mentors and the mentors are stoically noble because the kids are watching them for clues. That such self-sacrifice makes for people who become fearsomely good at killing is one of the paradoxes of such value systems. And so they fight in a welter of mud and blood and brutality, punctuated by skill and elegance, and sheer bad luck. Nobody hopes to survive, so they fight with the berserker power of bleakness. 

 


“Be silent like the decorative man you are.”
Shimada however seems to have gained in awareness by the end of this calamitous bloodbath. He fights Hanbei, most unwillingly but determined to end this lunatic lord’s life. He even realizes Hanbei is the more idealistic person, for he is willing to ‘cheat’ to win a fight, unlike their dojo days, kicking mud into Hanbei’s eyes and saying “See you in hell” before slicing  the head off. Shimada has the grim realization that he has become a monster too and is damned. Naritsugu kicks the decapitated head of Hanbei and assures Shimada he can do the same! And Shimada has a further realization; these great men, these lords, they are like decorative swords, useless for real work which has to be done by people like Hanbei and himself. The Great are so only because those below them support them, and he says Naritsugu has mistaken his decorativeness for the real thing, and the entire injustice of it strikes him too deeply. He does not even defend himself from a thrust made by Naritsufgu, though he stabs him in return and ensures this monster feels a little pain before the end. Naritsugu is at first bewildered, like the child he is, how can he die and how can he suffer, it is just not right, not the way things are meant to be. But before dying he thanks Shimada for providing him the most entertaining day of his life. Previously he had found the spectacle of killing so enthralling he wanted to break the peace Japan had been enjoying for almost two centuries and bring back the days of war when he was on the shoguns council. Like I said, basically a child. But Shimada has had enough of nobility and codes and urges his nephew to do whatever makes him happy in life, instead of continuing as a Samurai because that was the code. 

 

That would have been a good place to stop but Miike is too original a director to end like a moral science lesson. As the pensive nephew wanders through the abomination of desolation they have caused, a half dead soldier rises and tries to kill him. Instinctively he cuts the man down. He tries to fling the sword away but somehow it does not leave his hand. So he too has gained self- awareness and he returns to his girl with the knowledge that his true self might not be a romantic sighing at having to follow an uncongenial path but a nasty vicious killer who is very skilled at it.
It is an extraordinary conclusion to an amazing film. 

 
Rohit Arya is the Editor of The Leadership Review, and a corporate trainer. He has been a cultural critic and social commentator for two decades. Rohit is the author of 5 books and been published in 5 European languages. He is an Author, Yogi, Polymath. Rohit is also a Lineage Master in the Eight Spiritual Breaths system of Yoga