Wednesday, 30 November 2011

Rohit Arya on Alina Szapocznikow 1926 – 1973




  Sculpture Undone {1955 – 1972}

An artists’ biography is supposed to be irrelevant to the work. The only question of anything claiming to be artistic is – does it work? Does it make the viewer, the experiencer, shift in consciousness a bit? The artist is of interest but should not be of central import to the art itself. These are the standard givens… and I find them a little difficult to accept fully. Does it really not matter that Arthur Koestler was, and Roman Polanski is, a rapist? That Dali and Picasso were as close to being demonic as did not matter without actual hooves and horns? It can be argued that what an artist does in private life does not really have any import on the quality of the work – truly great poets have been fascists and racists and innumerable artists have proved to be congenital asses in anything other than their work. Shaw has tackled this question too in the preface to The Doctor’s Dilemma. If for a moment we rule out personal actions where does that leave personal experiences? What has happened to an artist, is that germane, even if we ignore what they do? Such thoughts began to clatter around in my mind when I saw some works by Alina Szapocznikow, {1926-1973} a Polish artist who was also a survivor of the Holocaust. They are first rate, extraordinary work, but how do we blank out what we know, how do we presume she did not have it burn in her consciousness each moment?  

 

Considering she died in 1973 the extraordinary freshness of her output is notable. It is obvious she is flitting with multiple genres simultaneously, pop art, surrealism, new realism, and the sheer sexual candour is bracing in any day or age. These works are funny, they bite, they comment, they mirror. It is socio-political manoeuvring without any overt agenda gravitas. Polyester resin casts and polyurethane forms are the basic materiel but the breezy and witty manner she works with are marvels. All the conceptual robustness and skill do not mask the central issue - at least for me – can such a person’s art ever be anything but autobiographical. Lips are repeated again and again, in counterpoise to the fearful silence that descended upon Europe in its nightmare years. Tellingly they are shaped as lamps… it gives you a terrible punch as you contemplate the implications. Light, free speech and thought even courage were almost extinguished in the heart of the apparently most civilized segment of the globe…

 

 The gravel which backdrops some pieces, chosen just for texture or for the memory of the rails resting on such gravel beds transporting unsuspecting people to perdition? Figures melt and fuse and fragment, how are we not supposed to recall the chambers where humans were seared down into collectibles? A vagrant breast, lumps of human organs, are they allusions or just neural patterns created by the guilt and shame in the mind of the viewer? Flowers grow out of partial visages – optimism and healing or a frank acknowledgment that Nature is a bitch and its cruelty is as impartial as its beauty? These fragments are terrifying in one sense, for survivors of great pain and trauma cohere their pain into a sanity creating narrative; but specific details, too close remembrance of little things, trivial things like gravel and flowers and scents can cause the entire horror to rush back and overwhelm the mind.

 

For something that is essentially aesthetically elegant these works are even more disconcerting as allusive talons.

Rohit Arya is the Editor of The Leadership Review, and a corporate trainer. He has been a cultural critic and social commentator for two decades. Rohit is the author of 5 books and been published in 5 European languages. He is an Author, Yogi, Polymath.


  

Monday, 7 November 2011

Rohit Arya reviews Places of Rebirth - Navin Jatak



                        

                          
In twenty years of reviewing art shows I never became part of the display. But Navin Rawanchaikul has a soft spoken persuasiveness that is very hard to refuse. Within 20 minutes of meeting him I was penning a little account of my personal brush with death, a rebirth, something that happened almost 36 years back, pushed into adjournments of memory, significant hence not recalled. Then the account went up on a wall, pinned in parallel to the memory, now a fixture in the mind. Evocativeness is not an easy quality to summon, but in his work and in his manner, Navin does it straightforwardly.  Smiling delightedly he gave me ‘gifts’, a flag with a flying porker and a passport to the truth, not the reality, that is Navinland. I declined making a video for him however; the writer in me is always more confident than the speaker, though the latter pays the bills. Ah, contradictions. Navin would understand. He has spent a lifetime pondering this.



Navin Rawanchaikul is a Thai artist, of Indian origins, with a Japanese wife and an eleven year old daughter. Actually his family originated in what is now Pakistan, just so that the convolution is compounded. Navin likes to write letters, and in one he wrote to his child he says that after hearing the stories of Partition, in his first trip to Pakistan, he understood why his family did not like to talk about those times. This is probably the most understated and excellent comment about the enduring trauma that is Partition. When he was leaving Pakistan the airport in Thailand was shut because of ‘troubles’, and the Mumbai terror attacks broke out simultaneously. His manner of processing this sensory overload is most delicate and shot through with a wry humour. He found a battered old refrigerator, complete with the paraphernalia of an old rotary phone, a picture, flowers in a bowl, magnets holding schedules and telephone numbers, the sheer fidelity of tone and spirit of what is being reproduced is remarkable. Over this striking assemblage he placed what appears to be a kitsch painting with ornate overdone frame. When you look closely it is the domes of the Taj Hotel in flames from the explosives of the terrorists with the pigeons obscuring the foreground. What seems a little nostalgic joke, when it all clicks into place, it hits you like the kick of a mule.




Next to the fridge is a looped video, candid camera style free association speeches of Thai Indians, usually of the older generation. They all fervently proclaim they are Thai – now - and there is no reason to disbelieve them. They are also so uniquely Indian; the houses are the same, the décor, the fears, the aspirations, the unique sense of resignation and gratitude, none of this is alien to us in India. “There is no family left over there,” explains an old lady – “so this is my country now.” In that unselfconscious statement is centuries of conditioning, layers of culture and systems of socialization. The primacy of the family is, not unchallenged, but deferred to. Even Navin, in a letter he wrote to his mother after her death, confesses he had begun a relationship with a Japanese girl who he has now married, but he kept it from his mom, as he knew she would prefer he marry within the group. This sort of choice, this sort of decision, is a basic reality in Indian life. It informs one’s stratagems of survival, it creates the sort of person one becomes, and this handling of multiple dimensions of thought and feeling make the Indian a very flexible, very creative personality. Some would say confused; Navin spent his childhood trying to be Thai alone, and found himself repeating his parents’ advice to his daughter, facing the same teasing for ambiguous identity in Japan “ Be yourself and respect your roots”. This manner of crucible, with its psychological stresses and demands, is either the making of a person or causes the person to contract. Navin has obviously found massive creative juice in handling this unique scenario.     
 
The centre piece of the show are two large paintings facing off with a gigantic image of Navin and his daughter doing what seems to be the goosestep in the centre. The paintings are overwhelming in their addressing of the kitsch factor of popular culture in both India and Pakistan. Designed to mimic film posters they have a tremendous overblown vitality, an in your face tastelessness that is actually more innocence than arrogance. However within the top corners of each, lurk little patches of resonant detail. Indians complain that foreigners are only interested in recording exotica, yet even Navin put in the same elephants and processions. Perhaps India does not recognize how exotic it remains? One is the view from Pakistan, the other is the view into Pakistan, from the land border crossing between the two countries.



The Goosestep imagery was inspired by a daily buffoonery that the guards of both countries perform in the evening when they lower the flags. It is a form of ritual theatre, it draws tourists and viewers, and has unfortunately become a life form of its own with self-perpetuating validation. The men in uniform stamp and grunt and throw high kicks and wheel and pirouette; it is supposed to awe and intimidate the enemy. Navin draws it with pizazz. Who exactly began this foolishness is now alas unknown; but once begun, izzat – honour, face, required it be continued. The resemblance to strutting roosters is, of course, lost on all participants. The Pakistanis put on the more vigorous detailed show typically; they have not managed to get a life since 1947 so that is to be expected. But it is a childish thing to do, an immature sensibility of power, a juveniles’ game and Navin throws up his boot in glee, holding the passport of Navinland, his imaginary place of freedom – all kindred spirits are invited – and in his daughter’s image is placed a flag with the airborne porcine indicating the potential of the phrase – ‘when pigs fly’. To juxtapose such an artefact next to a painting of Pakistani border post, the man has intestinal fortitude and more than a really dry wit.



That wit is seen in his self- portrait, wearing a jacket that I do not have the vocabulary to describe, you can see it in the pictures, but posed in the manner of the official portraits of Kim Il Jong! His other works have his daughter inserted into them as a leitmotif, they create a poignant effect, as timelines and history are merged. One of them even became a video story his wife told their daughter. This sort of work is not merely or even primarily a search for identity. Nor is it autobiography, though all of them contribute. Navin creates mythology, which navigates change, migration, aging, but most importantly acceptance.

Navin Rawanchaikul is the recipient of the national Silapathron citation from the Thai Ministry of Culture in the field of visual arts. He was Thailand’s representative for the 54th Venice Biennale in 2011. He lives in Thailand and Japan.

Places of Rebirth {Navin Jatak} will be on at the Sakshi Gallery Mumbai till November 22, 2011. Guest Curated by Steven Pettifor.

Rohit Arya is the Editor of The Leadership Review, and a corporate trainer. He has been a cultural critic for two decades. Rohit is the author of 5 books and been published in 5 European languages. He is an Author, Yogi, Polymath.