Tuesday, 11 October 2011

Rohit Arya reviews The Other JJs by Julius Macwan




Rohit Arya reviews The Other JJs
 By Julius Macwan
Conversations with Sudharshan Shetty, Bose Krishnamachari and Jitesh Kallat

Books on the early years of artists are rarer than hen’s teeth in India. Books which talk about the institutions that provided them with the significant formative educational experience in their creative lives are also not to be seen. In such a scenario, this book of conversations, by artist Julius Macwan, with distinguished fellow J. J. School of Art Mumbai alumni, Sudharshan Shetty, Bose Krishnamachari and Jitesh Kallat, representing 3 different artistic generations, this book is a very good initiative. Documentation, the record, these are important things even if creative people may find them irksome. An interesting, even intriguing, picture emerges of the weltanschauung that prevailed in the 1980s and 90s of what is one of the most important art schools of India. What is slightly depressing is that this book was only possible as a tribute to a friend of Julius, an artist called Ramdas Tadka, who died of cancer in 2010. Out of such melancholia emerges value.

Sudarshan Shetty makes a throwaway reference on page 29 to something immensely important, the need for artists to survive before they can thrive. “...there is this fantastic water colour artist I know, but I think his work lacks something. To my mind. But he has his own world to survive in and he survives there very well. And I am sure he has his own world of issues.” This is a crisply concise summation of the dilemma confronting a creative person who has to depend on his talent and skill to make a living, and may not have the luxury to integrate, to develop, to find authenticity. Bose has a hilarious memory of Owais Husian, son of the successful M.F., using up paint tubes like there is no tomorrow. So many choices, many possibilities are circumscribed by financial parameters. It was the reason Tadka never quite managed to become visible, the daily grind proved insurmountable. In all the romance about art this brutal reality is too easily overlooked. It is Bose however who also provides the unsentimental counterbalance.  “So we didn’t have the freedom – the economic freedom, which is a good thing – I won’t say there was a struggle, I would never say I struggled, we struggled – that is a kind of cliché, you know. It is all part of your life, man.”

Shetty also narrates an incident which shows the remarkable generosity that prevailed between fellow in the years between 1980 and 2000. Feeling the lacunae in the course work he went up to the already promising Atul Dodiya and asked to be taught about modern art. Dodiya called him home and gave him a full lecture, in Hindi, from impressionism to Cezanne. Now this is a very peculiar incident indeed. Dodiya, a Gujarati, lectures Shetty a Kannadiga, in the national language Hindi, in the state of Maharashtra. What is striking is how nobody seems to find it odd or unique at all; it is a tribute to their generosity as well as the inclusive nature of Indian society. As the reminiscences of the 3 artists flow, incident after incident emerges of artists freely helping each other in quite notable manners. If J. J. created people with such a mind-set then it was a remarkable place indeed.

The book is worth perusing for the smooth flow of ideas and the manner in which conversations shape realizations. There are no highlights so as to speak, it is all value. Shetty, Bose and Kallat are all highly articulate and not shy of speaking up. What struck me however was that the entire context of these conversations - of family background, of migrant city culture, or familiarity and distress was a larger social process being played out in a beautiful alternate reality called J. J. Macwan understood this, understood that in many ways J. J. was a peculiar, unique bubble. But the process playing out in that bubble was the larger one that India is still grappling with – what do we do with a modernity that is insistently dismantling enduring structures of behaviour and perception? There are no simple answers, indeed it is doubtful if any complete answers are possible, in the spirit of Bose’s observation – “Everything that is temporary is beautiful, more vibrant”

Jitesh Kallat in that sense represents the shift to the electronic age that India came to in the 2000s. He is too self- aware not to recognize its import. “I remember getting completely drawn into this visual spectacle of TV. …going into a kind of cracked wall, graffiti, the figuration, there was written text, there was the possibility of sounds completely crazy and meaningless and absurd – all came out of this possibility that television provided that I would think was my parallel university.” This is more significant that it sounds for it was a crack in the typical J. J. approach which is to privilege skill and experiential knowledge. That is wonderful but the usual J. J. product seems to feel that all other forms of knowledge are somehow invalid. Personal experience can become a fetish that proudly blocks off sources of knowledge, resulting in a clever ignorance. The inevitable feeling of irritation with the Baroda school’s intellectual approach flows from this encased perspective. Jitesh got so mad at the “this is how it should be” line that during a test, he spewed out a line of water between himself and the examiners and launched a mini non-cooperation movement. The book provides such illuminating slices of personal history, though not nearly as much as we could have hoped for. For instance who knew that Bose Krishnamachari, enfant terrible of his time, was once for a whole year a faculty member at J. J.? Of course he got flung out, that much was predictable, given who he was {and remains} and what the prevailing attitude of J. J. was. It must have been a wonderful spectacle however.  

The Book was released to coincide with a posthumous exhibition of Ramdas Tadka’s work entitled The Absent Weaver.

Rohit Arya is the Editor of The Leadership Review. He has five published books, one  translated into 5 international languages. He is an Author, Yogi, Polymath. 

No comments:

Post a Comment